Why scout programs are so attractive — and so complex

On paper, scout programs seem like a clear win for everyone involved.

• VC firms get a distributed network of eyes and ears, finding promising startups before they’re on the formal fundraising radar.
• Scouts get the chance to invest someone else’s money, build a track record, and potentially earn meaningful carry if a startup takes off.
• Founders get small checks quickly, often from people they trust as peers.
  

But because these programs sit between informal friendships and formal venture deals, they come with unique complications. Relationships can blur, expectations can misalign, and small oversights can lead to big misunderstandings.

Common pitfalls in scout models

1. Blurry incentives and mixed loyalties

Scouts often wear multiple hats: they might be founders running their own companies, casual angel investors, or even employees at large tech companies. At the same time, they’re scouting on behalf of a VC.

This can create situations where it’s not clear whose interests they’re prioritizing. Are they bringing deals to the fund because it’s genuinely the best fit, or because they want to impress the partner and secure future opportunities?

2. Information leakage — even if unintentional

Founders sometimes confide sensitive details to scouts, not realizing that scout might pass along insights to the VC firm backing them.

Even if there’s no ill intent, scouts naturally want to prove their value by surfacing interesting opportunities. That can inadvertently expose a founder’s early plans, strategy, or even financials before they’re ready to formally fundraise.

3. No guaranteed follow-on from the fund

Many founders mistakenly assume that if a scout from Firm X invests, Firm X will automatically consider leading their seed or Series A. But scout checks are typically very separate from the main fund’s diligence process.

This can lead to awkwardness later, especially if the founder was banking on that relationship as a pipeline to a larger round.

4. Regulatory and compliance gray zones

Most scout programs are carefully structured to avoid regulatory issues, especially around broker-dealer rules. But when scouts start introducing companies purely to get a finder’s fee — without taking on investment risk — it can raise compliance flags.

That’s why most established programs compensate scouts through carry, not cash commissions.

What VC firms can do to keep things clean

• Require clear disclosures. Many top firms now insist scouts tell founders upfront: “I’m investing through a scout program funded by [Firm Name].” It sets expectations early.
• Use lightweight NDAs or confidentiality norms. While full NDAs are rare, setting expectations that sensitive details won’t be casually shared back helps build trust.
• Offer educational support. The best programs train scouts not just on how to spot startups, but on how to navigate founder relationships with transparency.

What scouts themselves can watch out for

• Be upfront about your role. Let founders know from day one that you’re investing through a scout arrangement, and that it might lead to conversations with the parent fund — or it might not.
• Keep clean personal boundaries. If you’re both scouting for a fund and angel investing personally, be clear about when you’re writing your own check versus investing on behalf of someone else.
• Protect founder trust. Many scouts win long-term reputation by not instantly forwarding every pitch to their fund. Building a reputation for discretion often pays off in better deal flow.

What founders should keep in mind when taking scout checks

• Ask who’s behind the money. Is the scout investing personal funds, or on behalf of Sequoia, Lightspeed, a16z, or another firm? It changes follow-on dynamics.
• Don’t overinterpret the signal. A scout check doesn’t guarantee the parent VC will lead your next round. It’s more like a friendly toe in the water.
• Be mindful of what you share. Especially in the early stages, limit highly confidential plans until you’re sure how information flows. It’s completely reasonable to ask, “Who else at your firm sees this deck right now?”

The upside still outweighs the challenges

None of these pitfalls mean scout programs are a bad idea. In fact, they’re often the fastest route for founders to get early belief capital, for scouts to break into venture, and for firms to broaden their pipeline.

Handled thoughtfully, scouting relationships become some of the strongest partnerships in tech. Many legendary investments — from Uber to Stripe — started through a scout referral or check.

It just takes clear communication, aligned expectations, and a little extra diligence on all sides to avoid the traps that come with these uniquely personal investing relationships.

‍